PHI 216: ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS
Dr. David J. Yount
Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies
Philosophy & Religious Studies/Psychology/Business Building
(BP Building - #43A), Room BPO 13
Office phone: 480-461-7833
MWF 11:00 a.m. - 12:00 p.m., TR 11:45
a.m. - 12:45 p.m., or by appointment.
You are encouraged to drop by my office to talk about the course, especially if you have difficulties with the course. If you are unable to come to my office during my office hours, please set up another time for us to meet with me. I will check email during the week and possibly during the weekend; if you have an emergency, it is best to leave a message on my voicemail. When you send an email to me or leave a voicemail, please be sure to write "PHI 216" in the subject line or somewhere in the email (so I can know which section you're in), or mention it in your voicemail. Please note that if you have any problems or concerns about this course, mcc policy states that you must try to work the problem out with me first -- the Chair cannot get involved until that point. Also, the Chair cannot change your grade on any assignment or for the course.
Webpage Note: Some of my webpage (see above) may
not work if you use Microsoft Internet Explorer from a PC
(non-MAC); they might have weird characters such as question
marks in odd places. Instead, use FireFox, Safari, Google
Chrome, or some other browser for the best results! If you
encounter a link that does not work (except those that
say "Available when Dr. Y announces in class"), let me know and I will promptly
Canvas Note: No part of this course is on Canvas; you will also not be required to go on Canvas for any reason for this course.
Ethics: Readings in Theory and Application. Louis P.
Pojman, Paul Pojman, Katie McShaine, eds.
Seventh Edition (2017).
Rulebook for Arguments. Anthony Weston. Fourth edition.
In this course we shall examine and assess many different ethical theories concerning the environment, comparing and contrasting them as we apply these theories to different environmental ethical issues. After a brief introduction to what philosophy and ethics are, we will examine ethical perspectives concerning the environment, such as animal rights, naturalism, biocentrism, holism, deep ecology, environmental justice, ecofeminism, sustainability, economics, capitalism and the environment, food ethics, climate change, population and consumption, and pollution (see Reading List below).
Philosophical consideration of diverse theories and perspectives on the environment, and application of these theories to global moral issues such as animal rights, preservation of wilderness and species, population, world hunger and poverty, and air and water pollution. The Course Competencies are here.
COURSE PHILOSOPHY, PROMISES AND EXPECTATIONS:
COURSE PHILOSOPHY: Philosophy is a difficult but rewarding discipline. Like life, which at times can be frustrating and hard to figure out (e.g., what should I do with my life, what happens when I die, is there a God, etc.) but which at times can also be exhilarating and fun, philosophizing can have these qualities. The only way to get better at living or philosophizing is to actively deal with the relevant issues and put an honest effort into attempting to understand them. I look at philosophy as a skill that one cannot learn without actively participating. I do not want you to memorize names and dates and definitions and leave the class forgetting what material we covered. In an attempt to engage you more than I have in the past, I will require that you present an article to the class (see below). I will be available to help you, and you are free to search the Internet to see if someone else has written something on the article you're reading, etc. I want us to create an atmosphere where we are a team (even though I might know more about philosophy, I do not know everything), trying to sort out what the best view on these issues is, and where you're an essential part of the team. We need open and honest dialogue that includes respect (i.e., no name calling, accusations, verbal attacks, keeping the discussion and comments on the topic and not on the individual), keeping in mind that it is OK to disagree with each other.
PROMISES (WHAT I PROMISE YOU): I promise you that I will (1) Be on time; (2) Teach the course unless I am very ill; (3) Be enthused about philosophy and the class material every class session; (4) Help you understand the material to the best of my ability; (5) Be available outside of class in the form of phone, e-mail, and office hours; (6) Treat you with respect; (7) Grade fairly and promptly (I will have grades on papers returned no later than one week from when they were turned in, pending unforeseen circumstances); (8) Lay out course expectations and requirements clearly; (9) Be organized and use class time well; and (10) Inject as much humor as philosophically possible so that we can have fun!
EXPECTATIONS (WHAT I EXPECT YOU TO DO): I expect you to (1) Do the work (e.g., the reading, summaries, test, and papers) honestly and promptly; (2) Come to class; (3) Be on time; (4) Participate actively; (5) Ask a question whenever something is confusing or unclear; (6) Respect each other; (7) Support/share with each other; (8) Learn a lot; and (9) Have fun!
FOR ACADEMIC SUCCESS: For every hour you spend in
class, you should spend at least two (2) hours outside of
class studying the material and completing your assignments.
For instance, in this class, that comes to 5.5 hours of work
a week outside of class. Students do not fail at the end of
the semester. If a student is failing in the last week, it
is because of what he or she has done throughout the
semester. Keep up with the work. Keep track of your
summaries and grades on your presentation and papers.
WRITING CENTER: The Writing Center provides one-on-one appointments to help students during any phase of the writing process: brainstorming, prewriting, researching, drafting, and revising. The Writing Center is located on the 1st floor of the Elsner Library. Phone: 480.461.7513. Web: https://www.mesacc.edu/departments/english/writing-center[MCC has a Learning Enhancement Center, but there is not a tutor specifically for philosophy, but I will be happy to help you at any time Iím available. Just ask; I cannot help you with any problems if you do not let me know about it.]
STUDENTS: If you are an F-1 student, I
am happy that you are in our class! You bring diversity
and a world perspective to the classroom, and that helps
me fulfill one of MCC's student outcomes: Cultural and
Global Engagement. Please know that you must adhere to
the attendance policy (and other policies, such as the
"no plagiarism" policy) that is listed in this syllabus.
If you are withdrawn by me for the class for
non-attendance (or plagiarism), I will not place you
back into the class. If you earn a W for non-attendance,
for instance, and this brings you below the required 12
credits that you need to maintain your F-1 status in the
USA, I will not change your grade to an F. You are given
the grade that you earn. If you fall out of status, you
can go through a process called "F-1 Reinstatement" with
the International Education (IE) Office, located in
Building 36E. IE regularly sends you messages to
your MCC email regarding immigration matters. Be sure to
check your email regularly. They also check attendance
reports for all F-1 students on a weekly basis. You are
here in the USA to be a student on your F-1 full-time
study visa, and IE will help you maintain that status.
COURSE REQUIREMENTS (Due dates and requirements are subject to change):
1. Attendance (Please see "Attendance" and "Tardiness" under "Class Policies" below).
2. Participation in Discussion: (10% of course grade).
To grade the discussion portion of the course, if you either ask one question or make one comment on that day that relates to the course lectures, presentations, or articles, then you will earn participation credit for that day. Your participation grade is calculated based on how often you talk during discussion times. To earn an "A" in participation, you must make one comment or ask one question at least half of the semester. From there, participation will be graded on a standard scale: Talking in half of the class meetings or more (90% -100% of half of the class meetings) earns an A for this portion of the course; 80% - 89% (of half the class meetings) earns a B; 70 - 79%, a C; 60 - 69%, a D; 59% or lower, a failing grade. BONUS: YOU WILL EARN AN "A" IN PARTICIPATION IF YOU HAVE NO (ZERO) UNEXCUSED ABSENCES FOR THE SEMESTER (See "Attendance" in the "Class Policies" Section below, for more information)!
3. Presentation(s): (10% of course grade).
During the semester, you will need to present at least one (and perhaps more, depending on the size of the class) article to the class, giving relevant information about the reading (See my "Presentation Guidelines" on my Website for material that is to be covered during the presentation). I will assign the articles near the beginning of the semester. I will present at least one article as an example before we continue with your presentations. There are three possible grades on the presentation: (1) If you are on time, are well-prepared and present the material in an organized way (according to my "Presentation Guidelines" on my Website), then you will earn an "A" on it; (2) if you are tardy (more than 5 minutes late by my watch), mainly read straight out of the book and not from your own notes, have not prepared well in general (e.g., skipping large parts of an article), or have no notes ready and you "wing it," you will earn a "C"; and (3) If you attend class but do not give a presentation, or if you have an unexcused absence on the day of your presentation, you will earn an "F" for that presentation. [I reserve the right to give any grade between an "A" and an "F" (such as an AB -- see below) should I deem it necessary.]
4. Article Summaries (30% of course grade)
For each article that is presented, including my first sample(s), you will need to turn in a handwritten summary of the reading(s) for that class period including at least one question you have about the reading. These summaries are due at the beginning of the class period and are NOT to be completed during class! See my "Article Summary Guidelines" on my website for more details. Your grade for the summaries will be based on how many you turn in: If you turn in 90-100% of them, you'll earn an A; if you turn in 80-89%, B; 70-79%, C; 60-69%, D; and 0-59%, F. Also, the deadline for turning in any summaries for excused absences are due (unless specifically arranged otherwise with Dr. Y) on or before the last day of class (i.e., not the final exam day).
5. Introductory Paper (At least 3 pages but no more than 4 pages, 10% of course grade). An introductory paper is an excellent way for you to find out what philosophy is about and for me to find out how you are doing, and since it is not worth much in the general scheme of things, you need not worry too much about your grade. The paper topic(s) will be posted on my Website and announced when they become available for printing; your papers must be a response to the questions on the Website. Note that, besides the standard grades of A, B, C, D, and F, I may issue a grade on papers of an AB, BC, CD, or DF, which are mid-grades, halfway between the two grades (see the chart below). I reserve the right to assign other mid-grades. These grades will be factored in at the end of the course to give an overall grade of A, B, C, D, or F (in accordance with MCC policy). For much further information on all papers [including, e.g., how the papers are graded (more specifically), good and bad paper examples, etc.], see my Web page. Due date: See Presentation Schedule.
6. Second Paper (4 - 6 pages, 15% of course grade). In this paper, you will be expected to raise at least one good objection to your position and reply to that objection. Due date: See Presentation Schedule.
7. Third Paper (4 - 6 pages, 25% of course grade). In this paper, you will be expected to raise at least two good objections to your position and reply to those objections. Due date: See Presentation Schedule.
Scale for papers:
your grade means on a 0 - 4 scale:
||4.0 (100% A)
||3.75 (94% A)
||3.5 (like an
||3.25 (like a
||2.75 (like a
||2.5 (like a
||2.25 (like a
||1.5 (like a
Your final grade will be based on all assignments receiving a 0 - 4; your assignments will then be weighted (10%, 15%, etc.) and added; you will end up with a number between 0 and 4, where:
3.45 - 4.0 will earn an A
2.45 - 3.44 will earn a B
1.45 - 2.44 will earn a C
0.45 - 1.44 will earn a D
0.0 - 0.44 will earn an F
Absences: For MWF students, if you have THREE (3) or more UNexcused absences over the course of the semester, I reserve the right to withdraw you from this course. Excused absences will only be given in cases of medical emergencies, jury duty, funerals, participation in school activities, religious observances, etc. (or at my discretion). I will require a physical copy of a physician's slip, a court order or summons, a funeral prayer card, etc., or the absence will not be excused. Also, I require advanced notice for excused absences, except in the case of medical emergencies, or your absence will not be excused. Examples of typical unexcused absences include: My car won't start, my windshield wipers don't work and it's raining, I have a bad cold or feel ill (unless you get a physician's slip for it), I overslept, I had to study for another class, I went home for a long weekend, I'm going skiing, etc. As noted in the MCC Student Handbook, if you have a religious observance for which you want to have an excused absence, you need to notify me of that at least one (1) week prior to the absence, so we can arrange what needs to be done. You will receive a W for excessive absences (as defined in the first sentence), unless you have extended excused absence (e.g., prolonged illness), in which case you need to make other arrangements with me, which may include withdrawing you from the course. Keep in mind that you may have so many absences (excused or unexcused), that I reserve the right to withdraw you from having excessive absences. If you come to class more than 20 minutes late, it will be considered an unexcused absence, unless you can prove otherwise. On the other hand, I would still urge you to come to class, to get whatever you can out of that day's reading, lecture, etc. You also cannot leave class with more than 5 minutes left without providing a reason for that, and I will be happy to excuse your absence if you can talk to me before class (or prove afterwards) why you need(ed) to leave. Lastly, it is the student's responsibility to ask for any information or work missed due to absences.
Tardiness: I reserve the right to withdraw you from the class if you are consistently late to class (e.g. 5 or 10 minutes). If you are late to class more than 3 times, I reserve the right to withdraw you from this course. What's the problem with being late? It disrespects the whole class - the teacher and your classmates - if you are habitually late. It breaks the concentration of most everyone in the room, and if you come in and start asking questions of those next to you, they will only miss more of the class as well. In the student handbook, it says that an instructor can withdraw a student from a class for disrupting the class, and being continually late falls under this category, as interpreted by me.
Attendance Sheet: It is completely your responsibility to make sure that I mark you as being present, on the attendance sheet. If you come in after I take roll, it is your responsibility to ask at the end of class if I got you on the roll. If you leave class without making sure I have you on the roll for that day, I may not remember you were there, and will not give you credit for being there.
Information for Students with Accommodation Needs: If you have a documented disability (as protected by the Americans with Disability Act) or if you are pregnant or parenting (as protected under Title IX) and would like to discuss possible accommodations, please contact the MCC Disabilities Resources and Services Office at 480-461-7447 or email email@example.com. Access to Course Materials: If you are experiencing difficulty accessing course materials because of a disability, please contact your instructor. All students should have equal access to course materials and technology.
Mobile Phones, Headphones, & Computers: (1) You may not use your phone during class (for browsing, social media and/or texting), unless I specifically give you permission to do so. You may use your phones in our classroom before class starts, however. Turn your phone off unless you have an important call you're expecting; then please leave the room to take the call, only if it it is an emergency. Note: If you think that it is going to be very hard for you to be without your phone, I will allow you to doodle in class. (I have read research that doodlers remember more from meetings than non-doodlers; click Here or Here for the study). (2) You may not have headphones in your ears or hanging from your ears, so I can make sure that you are not listening to anything else than us. (3) You may not use a computer in class unless you justify why you need to use it; for instance, you can tell me that you will only be taking notes every day in class with it. But I reserve the right to ask to see your notes on any given day during the semester. You may not go to any websites at any time (not only Facebook or any social media, but even philosophy websites) without asking me during class (e.g., "Dr. Y.: I would like to look up X"). Again, you may doodle if you think it will be hard to focus on the class without your computer. Keep in mind that a study shows that neither the user nor his/her classmates nearby will do as well in the course if one uses a computer in class (click Here for the study).
Audio-Recording the Class: The content of course
lectures, including, but not limited to, verbal, printed,
Powerpoint and other electronic communications are the
copyrighted property of the professor. Recording class
content is prohibited without express
written consent. If you wish to record lectures, you
must see me during office hours and sign a Proprietary
Information Agreement. (Of course, I will allow a disabled
student who is granted this accommodation from
Disabilities Resources to record the course content, provided
he/she signs the agreement.)
& Doing Homework in Class: You may not sleep in
class. If you are tired, sit near the back of the class and
you may stand for a bit to stay awake. You also may not do
any homework for any class, including my class, during our
class. Our class time is for trying to understand and
discuss the philosophers and their philosophies.
Warnings: If you do not like thinking or writing, do not take this course. I will be evaluating your critical thinking skills in discussions, in your article summaries, and in your papers, in order to gauge your comprehension of the material. To be a good philosopher (or philosophy student), as I view it, is not essentially to be able to memorize dates and definitions, but is to have the ability to actively engage in argument and critical thinking of one's own views as well as those of one's opponent. Philosophy deals with controversial adult material including human sexuality, the existence of God, principles of justice, etc. Students must be prepared to engage all material as presented and assigned. Alternate assignments, readings, lectures, etc. will not be provided.
Paper Deadlines: I accept no late papers (however, I will accept early papers). At my discretion, I may make other arrangements in advance; however, if any problem arises concerning that arrangement (e.g., not meeting the new agreed-upon deadline), I will revert back to the original "no late papers" policy.
Academic Integrity: Academic misconduct and dishonesty includes, but is not limited to, cheating, plagiarism, excessive absences, use of abusive or profane language, and disruptive and/or threatening behavior. All instances of academic dishonesty will be reported to the Chair of Philosophy and Religious Studies Department and other appropriate authorities. Students displaying acts of academic dishonesty are subject to grade adjustment, course failure, probation, suspension, or expulsion. See the Student Handbook for more information regarding cases of academic misconduct.
Plagiarism: Do not (attempt to) plagiarize in writing your papers. Plagiarism = taking any idea or writing that is not your own and including it in your paper without citing your source. Refer to this website: Plagiarism 101. For example, if you go to a website and take information or sentences from that website and do not cite that website in your paper, you are plagiarizing. You cannot have a roommate write your paper. You also cannot just cite a website and then turn in a whole paper from a website that is not your work. The paper has to be an original work of your own. This also includes using our own textbook, quoting it, or describing a philosopher's view and not citing the page from which you took the information. (See my Dr. Y's Philosophy 216 Paper Policies on my Website for how to cite sources.) How serious am I about this? On the first occurrence of plagiarism (this includes drafts with substantial amounts of plagiarism in them), you will receive a failing grade for the course. I will assume that you now realize what plagiarism is, what plagiarizing in my class results in, and that by continuing in my class you're in effect making a commitment not to plagiarize in this class. (NOTE: I will NOT be looking for plagiarism in your presentations or article summaries.)
Other academic misconduct: Anyone caught cheating on an exam by text messaging or by other means will automatically fail the test. Mobile phones cannot be answered during tests for any reason, and once the test is administered, no one may leave the room unless he or she has turned the test in for grading.
MCC Early Alert Program (EARS): Mesa Community College is committed to the success of all our students. MCC has adopted an Early Alert Referral System (EARS) to aid students in their educational pursuits. Faculty and Staff participate by referring students to campus services for added support. Students may receive a follow up call from various campus services as a result of being referred to EARS. Students are encouraged to participate, but these services are optional. http://www.mesacc.edu/students/ears
Student Email: You will need a student email account so that your instructor can communicate with you regarding course work and performance in this class, especially if, for some reason, our class is canceled, or you left something in class, and so on. This is available to all MCC students at no charge. Contact me through your Maricopa email. Setting Up Your Maricopa Email
Student Handbook: It is
your responsibility to understand the policies listed in this
syllabus as these are the guidelines that your instructor will
follow for grading, attendance, etc. It is also your
responsibility to read and understand the college policies
included in the student handbook as they may apply to you in
the case of an incomplete grade, withdraw for failure to
attend, etc. MCC
Tuition Charges and Refunds: Students who officially withdraw from credit classes (in fall, spring, or summer) within the withdrawal deadlines listed below will receive a 100% refund for tuition, class and registration processing fees. Deadlines that fall on a weekend or a college holiday will advance to the next college workday except for classes fewer than 10 calendar days in length or as specified by the college. Calendar days include weekdays and weekends. Refer to individual colleges for withdrawal and refund processes. Never attending is not an allowable refund exemption or an excuse of the debt incurred through registration.
Length of Class
Official Withdrawal Deadlines for 100% Refund
1-9 calendar days
Prior to the class start date
10-19 calendar days
1 calendar day including the class start date
20-29 calendar days
2 calendar days including the class start date
30-39 calendar days
3 calendar days including the class start date
40-49 calendar days
4 calendar days including the class start date
50-59 calendar days
5 calendar days including the class start date
60-69 calendar days
6 calendar days including the class start date
70+ calendar days
7 calendar days including the class start date
*Course fees and registration processing fees will be refunded only if the student qualifies for a 100% refund. Debts owed to any MCCCD college must be satisfied before any refunds are paid to the student. Refunds for students receiving federal financial assistance are subject to federal guidelines. Requests for exceptions to the refund policy must be filed within one year from the semester in which the course was taken.
TENTATIVE READING LIST (See Presentation Schedule for official reading list and the due dates for the reading):
I. What are Philosophy and Ethics? (Lecture Notes & Chapter I):
Lecture 1: Lecture Notes (from Dr. Y's Website)
Introduction, pp. 1-3.
What is Ethics?, Katie McShane, pp. 3-11.
Four Meta-Ethical Theories (Lecture Notes):
Lecture 2: Nihilism, (Objections to) Individual and Cultural Relativism, and Objectivism (from Dr. Y's Website)
Lecture 3: Immanuel Kant's Ethical Theory (from Dr. Y's Website)
Lecture 4: John Stuart Mill's Ethical Theory (from Dr. Y's Website)
II. theory (ETHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON THE ENVIRONMENT):Animal Rights (Chapter 3):
Article 7: Immanuel Kant, "Rational Beings Alone Have Moral Worth," pp. 85-87.
Article 9: Peter Singer, "A Utilitarian Defense of Animal Liberation," pp. 96-105.
Nature and Naturalness (Chapter 4):Readings:
Holism (Chapter 6):
Environmental Justice (Chapter 7):
32: Peter S. Wenz,
Garbage: The Problem
of Environmental Racism," pp. 332-340.
Article 33: Maria Mies, "Deceiving the Third World: The Myth of Catching-up Development," pp. 341-349.
Article 34: Laura Westra, "Environmental Risks, Rights, and the Failure of Liberal Democracy: Some Possible Remedies," pp. 341-349.
Article 37: Karen
J. Warren, "The Power and
the Promise of Ecological Feminism," pp. 389-402.
Sustainability (Chapter 8):
Readings:Article 41: William E Rees, "Sustainable Development: Economic Myths and Ecological Realities," pp. 433-441.
44: Fred Magdoff and John Bellamy Foster,
"What Every Environmentalist
Needs to Know about Capitalism," pp. 464-482.
III. practice (examining Contemporary Environmental Issues):
Food Ethics (Chapter 9):
Article 49: Michael Allen Fox, "Vegetarianism and Treading Lightly on the Earth," pp. 533-539.
Article 50: Jonathan Rauch, "Can Frankenfood Save the Planet?" pp. 542-548.
Article 51: Mae Ho, "The
Unholy Alliance," pp. 549-558.
Article 55: Eric Schlosser, Marion Nestle, Michael Pollan, Wendell Berry, Troy Duster, Elizabeth Ransom, Winona Laduke, Peter Singer, Vandana Shiva, Carlo Petrini, Eliot Coleman, and Jim Hightower, "One Thing to Do about Food," pp. 595-603.
Climate Change (Chapter 10):
Article 56: Naomi Oreskes, "The Scientific Consensus on Climate Change: How Do We Know We're Not Wrong?" pp. 608-622.
Article 57: UN Report:
Climate Change and Livestock, "Livestock's Role in Climate
Change and Air Pollution," pp. 628-646.
Article 60: Stephen Gardiner, "Ethics and Global Climate Change," pp. 674-687.
Population and Consumption
Article 63: Bill McKibben, "A Special Moment in History: The Challenge of Overpopulation and Overconsumption," pp. 716-727.
Article 64: Garrett Hardin, "The Tragedy of the Commons," pp. 728-737.
Article 66: Jacqueline Kasun, "The Unjust War Against Population," pp. 749-762.
Article 67: Garrett Hardin, "Lifeboat Ethics," pp. 763-771.
Article 68: William W. Murdoch and Allan Oaten, "Population and Food: A Critique of Lifeboat Ethics," pp. 772-777.
Pollution (Chapter 12):
Article 69: Hilary French, "You Are What You Breathe," pp. 781-788.
Article 70: David Watson, "We All Live in Bhopal," pp. 789-793.